A road made after Little Holland House
The demolition date is part of the street's identity. Little Holland House came down in 1875 so that Melbury Road could be made. It had been the dower house for Lady Holland and, later, the home of George Frederick Watts. Two artists' studio houses were already standing in Holland Park Road by then. The Earl of Ilchester's intention was large houses of quality on this land, and the appraisal's view is that the intention was met. Late twentieth century intrusions are acknowledged, and so are later buildings that interrupted the red-brick character of 1865-1905. Those later buildings kept a spacious setting and some relationship to the historic street pattern. They are not asked, by that account, to impersonate a studio-house, and a studio-house is not asked to take on the finish of a later neighbour.
Generous front and rear gardens are why the houses read as separate. They also change the work. Protection has to cross planting, and the elevation that matters may be as visible from the garden as from the pavement. Spaciousness is a recorded quality. Filling a forecourt, or treating a side gap as a place to lose materials, works against the setting the appraisal describes. The red brick of the 1865-1905 houses is the common material, not a common colour of paint. Several of the houses below show how differently that brick was handled within one street.
No. 7 and the black sash
No. 7 Melbury Road is a three-storey house in an asymmetrical design. A canted full-height bay stands to the left and ends in an almost conical roof, with a gable to the right. There is little decoration. What there is, the appraisal limits to brick quoins, black painted sash windows, and string courses in matching red brick. The black is on the sashes. The quoins and the string courses are red brick, matching the wall, not a painted trim waiting to be picked out in a contrasting masonry colour.
That split decides the job. Joinery can be redecorated black where it is already black painted sash. The brick, including quoins and string courses, is not a surface to coat so that the asymmetry 'reads more strongly', and it is not a surface to turn white because another house on the road has white windows. Older paintwork may contain lead. Lead pigments were widely used in household paints until the 1960s, so the black on those sashes is a reason to treat the existing paint as old paint. The material description is clear enough to specify from: red brick, little ornament, black sashes, a tall bay and a gable. Listing, if it applies to this number, is checked before any bare brick is coated.
No. 9, split in 1935 and put back together
No. 9 Melbury Road is grade II. It was built as no. 1 Melbury Road in 1880 by George Stephenson of Chelsea, perhaps coincidentally in the style of J.J. Stephenson, the early Queen Anne Revival architect. The appraisal does not say J.J. Stephenson designed it. It is a large house in four sections, two of them with bays of rubbed and decoratively carved brick under pedimented gables. The windows are sashes with multiple small panes over plain sashes. Roofs are tiled mansards, slightly compromised by modern rooflights. A glazed canopy leads to the front door. The boundary is railings on a low wall, with a hedge behind that the appraisal says contrasts pleasantly with the red brick. Tall decorative chimney stacks sit at both sides of the roof.
The planning history is a warning against specifying the house as two dwellings. It was built as one house, converted to two houses in 1935, East and West House, granted permission for flats in 1989, and converted back to a single house in recent years. The exterior to conserve is the 1880 composition: small panes over plain sashes, carved brick, pedimented gables, canopy, railings, hedge and stacks. Modern rooflights are already described as a slight compromise of the mansards. Painting them out, or painting the rubbed brick, is not how that compromise is addressed. Like-for-like redecoration of painted joinery, matching type, texture, finish and colour, is the work Historic England says usually does not need listed building consent. Painting bare brick or carved brick that is currently unpainted is likely to need it.
The Tower House is not a sample for the street
No. 29, the Tower House, was designed in 1875 by the Gothic architect William Burgess as his own home. It is grade I listed, in recognition of exceptional heritage value, and the original interiors are also by the architect. The same year, 1875, is when Little Holland House was demolished for the road. That shared date does not make the Tower House typical of the street. From outside it is a red brick house named for the round stair tower on the front, topped by a conical slate roof, with small windows of stained glass. The plan is L-shaped. The tower and an attached open square entrance porch fill the space to the right. Porch and dressings are stone. The gabled part has Tudor-style window surrounds with stone transoms and mullions, and blind trefoils over the first-floor openings. Chimney stacks are finished in moulded brick. The roofs are slate.
Grade I, with interiors by Burgess as well as the outside, means this is not a house on which to try a coating chosen for a neighbour's painted sash. Red brick, moulded brick stacks, stone dressings, slate and stained glass are materials first. Where they are unpainted, painting them is likely to need listed building consent, and it would also fight the account of the building. Stained glass is not a sash to be overpainted. Stone transoms and mullions are not given a joinery colour for the sake of consistency with no. 7 or with the white sashes further along. If any element is already painted, renewal in the same type, texture, finish and colour is the like-for-like case. The interiors are part of why the house is listed. They are not a scheme this exterior note can invent, and they are not a reason to treat the brick face as ordinary decorated stucco.
Salt-glazed brick, a 1925 neighbour, and a Dutch-gabled pair
Nos. 55-57 (odd) are rare works by Halsey Ricardo, designed in 1894. He used salt-glazed bricks meant to protect the houses from pollution and degradation. No. 59 is the smallest of that group, two storeys plus an attic, designed in 1925 by Williams and Cox of Covent Garden. Together they have multi-paned white painted sash windows. The white is on the sashes, as at many other London houses, but here it sits against salt-glazed brick chosen so that pollution would not eat the wall. That brick is not a primer for masonry paint. Whether these houses are listed has to be checked before anyone treats the wall as paintable. If they are listed, painting a currently bare surface is likely to need listed building consent. Even before that check, the reason the brick is salt-glazed is a reason not to hide it.
Nos. 16-18 (even) are a different case again, and they are listed. Built in 1877, grade II, they are a handed pair of semi-detached houses, extremely well conserved, with their features matching. Three main storeys, original half-basements, and an attic with dormers. The defining pieces are curving Dutch gables, square-section bay windows, mock-Tudor mullions and transoms, and brick and stucco porches. Windows are casements, with diamond leaded lights to the upper panes and small curved and triangular pediments over them. The porches are an open arch with carved brick to the pilasters, stone or stucco keystones, and balustrades above. Leaded lights are the window, not a pane to be painted over. Carved brick and the red brick of the pair stay as brick. Stucco in the porches and balustrades is the masonry that may already be painted, and on a grade II pair that paint is renewed like for like. The fact that the two houses match is itself the conservation point. Specifying one of them in a different colour from its pair would undo the thing the appraisal praises.
Hedges, boarding, and consent that may sit on top of listing
Some detached houses in the Melbury area have railings and hedges, which the appraisal calls a very pleasant finish. It regrets that boarding has often been added behind the railings, making a solid, impermeable appearance. The hedge behind railings at no. 9 is described with pleasure, as a contrast to the red brick. Boarding that closes the same kind of railing is the opposite judgement. A decorating note should say which of the two is there. Painting the boarding a garden green, or the colour of the brick, does not turn it into the hedge the appraisal prefers, and it can make the solid screen look deliberate. Railings themselves, where they are iron, are metalwork. They are not improved by being backed with a painted sheet as part of the same item.
Consent on this road can come from more than one direction, and they are not substitutes. Historic England's like-for-like advice, and the warning about painting bare surfaces, apply to the listed houses for certain, and have to be considered wherever listing is confirmed. Ordinary repainting of a house does not need planning permission, with listed buildings and Article 4 areas as the exceptions to check. Separately, where a house stands on the Ilchester estate, written consent from the Ilchester Estates is required for any external alteration to its appearance. That consent is in addition to planning permission or listed building consent, which may also be required from the Royal Borough. The Earl of Ilchester's intention for this land does not, by itself, prove that a present title is still on the estate. The estate's own written position answers that. It is not something this page can decide from the street name.
Choosing the right neighbouring page
An enquiry that says only 'Melbury Road, red brick' has not yet said whether the sashes are the black ones at no. 7, the small-panes-over-plain at no. 9, the stained glass of the Tower House, the white multi-paned sashes of nos. 55-57 and no. 59, or the leaded casements of nos. 16-18. Those are different specifications. Photographs of the whole garden front, the boundary, and one window at close range are the minimum that distinguishes them. Say if boarding sits behind the railings. Say if there is already an estate letter.
Heritage coatings are the right service conversation where listing, salt-glazed brick, stone and unpainted red brick are the issue. The Holland Park area guide holds the wider map. Ilchester Place and the Holland Park villas are separate guides. Neither is a pattern for these red-brick houses.
Sources for this page
The building points above are taken from the documents linked here. Preparation, protection and the order of work are general decorating practice, and they are not quotations from those documents.
Sources
Questions about Melbury Road
Do the Melbury Road houses share one window colour?
No. No. 7 has black painted sashes, with brick quoins and red brick string courses, and little other decoration. Nos. 55-57, designed by Halsey Ricardo in 1894 in salt-glazed brick, and no. 59, designed in 1925, have multi-paned white painted sashes. Nos. 16-18 have casements with diamond leaded lights to the upper panes. The Tower House has small stained-glass windows in a round stair tower.
What is listed on this road, on the appraisal's account?
No. 9 is grade II, built as no. 1 in 1880 by George Stephenson of Chelsea, later split into two houses in 1935, given permission for flats in 1989, and since returned to one house. Nos. 16-18, built in 1877, are a grade II handed pair with Dutch gables. No. 29, the Tower House, was designed in 1875 by William Burgess as his own home and is grade I, including interiors by the architect. Nos. 55-57 are Halsey Ricardo's salt-glazed houses, designed in 1894, and no. 59, designed in 1925, has the same multi-paned white painted sashes. Listing for those numbers still has to be checked before bare brick is painted.
Why does the Tower House need a different specification?
It is grade I, red brick and stone, with a conical slate roof to the stair tower, a stone porch, Tudor-style stone transoms and mullions, moulded brick stacks and slate roofs. Painting a currently unpainted surface on a listed building is likely to need listed building consent. Like-for-like renewal of paint that is already there, matching type, texture, finish and colour, usually does not. The house was Burgess's own, and the interiors are his as well.
What extra consent can apply, beyond the borough?
For a house on the Ilchester estate, written consent from the Ilchester Estates is required for any external alteration to its appearance. That consent is additional to planning permission or listed building consent, which may also be required from the Royal Borough. The road was laid out on land the Earl of Ilchester intended for large houses after Little Holland House was demolished in 1875. Whether a present house is still on the estate is a separate question. Some Melbury houses also have railings and hedges, and boarding fixed behind the railings is the finish the appraisal regrets.