Name stucco, stock brick, render and tile before any colour
Write the substrate in the first line of the note, and write it for each face, not for the house as a nickname. The Holland Park houses are fully stuccoed to the front and the rear, and to sides that front a street, but stock brick on the flanks that do not. James Hall's nos. 62 and 64-84 on Addison Road are the same kind of split in a different contract: fully stuccoed to the front, stock brick to the sides and rears, with a square-section bottle balustrade and blocked quoins on the stucco. One coating schedule for 'the white house' will hit brick on the return and stucco on the street. They are prepared apart.
Render is a third word, and it is earned by the building, not used as a synonym for stucco. No. 63 Addison Road, built in 1829, keeps a render finish, with arched ground-floor openings and very large York flag stones on the path. Warwick Villas, nos. 40-47, are all rendered and linked, including the rear elevations, with high gables, battlements and timber casements. Those rendered fronts are not assumed to be the same build-up as a Radford stucco bay or a Hall porch. Tile is a fourth material, and on this road it belongs to Debenham House. Debenham House, no. 10, is grade I, built between 1905-07, with green and blue tiles filling arched recesses around multi-paned sashes. A wash-down and a masonry coating specified for previously painted stucco has no business on that glaze.
- Stucco: street fronts and street-facing sides of the Holland Park houses, and the fronts of Hall's Addison Road villas, including quoins and bottle balustrades.
- Stock brick: flanks that do not front a street on the Holland Park houses, and the sides and rears of the Hall villas.
- Render: the finish recorded on no. 63 Addison Road, and the linked houses of Warwick Villas, fronts and rears.
- Tile: the green and blue external tiles of Debenham House, which are not a stucco colour match for the villas beside them.
Leave the brick the appraisal says is harmed when it is painted
Fair-faced brick is not an unfinished stucco wall. On Upper Addison Gardens and Lower Addison Gardens the appraisal says the uniformity of the terraces is well maintained, and that most houses retain attractive fair-faced stock brick frontages. That is a record of what has survived, and it is the condition to keep. A proposal to paint those frontages so they look more 'finished' would spend the quality the document has just praised.
Holland Road is the place where the harm has already happened in part. The elaborate terrace is harmed by the overpainting of red brick arches and, worst in the appraisal's own order of complaint, by the complete painting of some stock brick elevations. Overpainted arches and painted stock brick sit in the same list as lost sashes, bitumen on the steps, lost railings and out-of-character roof extensions. Preparation for a repaint on that terrace includes a decision not to extend the painted area onto stock brick that is still unpainted, and not to treat an already painted brick elevation as a model for its neighbours.
Holland Park Mews makes the point from the other direction. A few mews remain unpainted, or have had paint removed, which the appraisal calls a welcome reinstatement of the original brick finish. Beaded stucco balustrades above the cornices are a different material and stay in the stucco conversation. The brick that has been revealed is the success. Cutting back failed paint on a mews that is already painted is not the same decision as coating a unit whose brick has been deliberately put back on show. If the brief is unclear, the photograph of that bay is the question to settle before a masonry product is ordered for it.
Cut back only the coating that has failed
Sound paint is not a fault. The preparation standard used here is to wash the surface down, find what is loose, and cut back only the coating that has failed. Blown areas, flakes and edges that have opened are taken back to a firm boundary. Paint that is still attached is left, so the wall is not stripped for the sake of a bare, even substrate that the building does not need. That approach also limits how much old material is turned into dust.
HSE notes that lead pigments were widely used in household paints until the 1960s, so older paintwork may contain lead. Leaded paint must not be overheated with blow lamps or gas torches. Sound old paint is left in place, and paint is stripped back only where it is flaking, chipping or dusting. Burning a Holland Park front back to the moulding, because that feels more thorough, is the opposite of this guidance. It is also a poor way to keep a cornice crisp. The failed film comes off. The sound film stays. Anything beyond that is a separate specification, not a default.
Fill cracks and open mouldings that are in the decorating scope
A crack that is in scope is filled before it is painted. Bridging it with a heavy coat leaves a line that opens again and throws the colour. The fill is kept to the crack. It is not used to reinvent a profile. Open mouldings, quoins and the edges of a bottle balustrade are treated the same way: the loose edge is made good, and the shape that is already there is kept readable. Flooding a modillion or a blocked quoin until it looks smooth is damage done in the name of preparation.
Not every crack is decorating work. A movement crack, a failed flashing above a bay, or a balcony that is shedding stucco because the structure behind it has gone are reasons to stop and say so. They are identified in the note as outside the coating line, not quietly filled and painted. On these villas the ornamental parts are the architecture. The Holland Park houses carry ornamented dormers and cornices; Hall's villas carry porches, pediments and quoins. Preparation protects that ornament by refusing to bury it, and by refusing to pretend that paint is a repair to the fabric underneath.
Sample the colour on the elevation, not on a card indoors
Pale cream is a rule with a boundary, and the boundary is the Holland Park houses rather than the whole conservation area. All of those houses are painted in pale colours, though on close inspection not always the same one. The appraisal says the walls should stay pale cream and should not stray into greys, yellows, pinks or any other colour. A sample board in a hallway cannot show whether a cream has tipped towards grey in the light of that particular front. The sample belongs on the elevation, next to the detailing, and it is read in daylight.
The other recorded contrast used in preparation is on Hall's Addison Road group. Most windows there are painted black against the cream stucco. A black sample is judged on the sash, against that cream, on the house, not against a printer's idea of black. If the stucco cream and the joinery black are both being renewed, they are sampled together. Changing one without looking at the other is how a contrast the appraisal describes becomes a mismatch. Neither sample is then carried, untested, onto fair-faced brick or onto the tiles of Debenham House.
Stop before coating a listed surface that is still bare
Historic England warns that painting a currently unpainted surface on a listed building is likely to need listed building consent, whether or not that surface was painted at some time in the past. The test is the surface as it is now. A flank of stock brick that has never been coated, or a mews front from which paint has been removed, is currently bare. Putting a masonry coating on it is not 'bringing it into the scheme'. On a listed building it is the kind of change the advice says is likely to need consent.
The Holland Park houses, including the mews, are a listed group, and Debenham House is grade I. Listing is still confirmed for the address rather than assumed from a photograph of a neighbour. What the preparer can see, and must not quietly overpaint, is the bare material itself: fair-faced stock brick on the Addison Gardens terraces, stock brick that the Holland Road appraisal says is harmed when it is completely painted, and mews brick the appraisal is glad to see. If the instruction is to coat one of those, the instruction is the thing that changes, not the wall.
Choose a coating for previously painted stucco, then work downwards
When the wall is previously painted stucco, the coating is chosen for that stucco. It is not a product picked because it is convenient for bare brick, and it is not a brick paint stretched over a moulded front so that one tin will do. Render that is already painted, such as the finish on no. 63 or on Warwick Villas, is specified as the render it is, not relabelled as the Radford stucco system because both look pale at a distance. Tile stays out of the tin. Fair-faced brick stays out of the tin.
The order on the elevation is from the top downward. Cornice, dormer cheeks, balustrade and upper wall are completed before the lower storey is coated, so that later washing and splash do not spoil finished work below. Steps, paths, York flag stones, iron railings and any brick that is meant to remain visible are protected before the first coat goes on. Floors inside, where windows are open or decorators pass through, are protected as well. The system itself, including how many coats and which product, is stated in the specification for that address. It is not fixed by a page of general guidance, and it is not copied from a neighbouring street whose material is different.
If the front also includes timber sashes or cast iron, those are prepared on their own lines and finished in the colour that street records, unless a change has been checked. The guides on sashes and on railings take those lines further. The local guide to period homes sets out which street is which. A quotation follows a look at the building. It is not a ready-made sum for a stucco house.
Sources for this page
The building points above are taken from the documents linked here. Preparation, protection and the order of work are general decorating practice, and they are not quotations from those documents.
Sources